Economics · Financial, Credit and Business Indicators
Stock Market Cycles
Stock prices are far more volatile than output, and than the dividends they are a claim on (Shiller, 1981). This page measures how the US stock market moves over the business cycle: the cyclical components of stock prices, dividends, earnings and valuation ratios, their volatility and co-movement with output, their leads and lags, and their correlations with the variables of the Real Business Cycles page. The levels and growth rates of these series are on Main Stock Market Indicators.
Filter comparison: each chart shows its variable under the three filters; the tables show the HP filter.
- The Values switch applies to every variable with a real and a nominal version: stock prices, dividends and earnings, and output, consumption, investment, government spending, exports, imports, hourly compensation and labour productivity. Hours, capital services, TFP, unemployment, participation, inflation and interest rates are the same under both (they have no price dimension, or are nominal already); the real interest rates stay real.
- Per capita divides the aggregate quantities (output, corporate dividends and the other aggregates of the Real Business Cycles page) by the population; the S&P 500 series, measured per share of the index, and the valuation ratios do not change.
- Every series is filtered from 1947 Q1, as on Real Business Cycles; charts and statistics start in 1950 Q1. Shaded bands mark US recessions (USRECQ).
Cyclical components
Each chart compares the cyclical component of a stock-market series, its percentage deviation from trend, with that of output, drawn in red.
Total or per capita with the switch at the top of the page.
Volatility and co-movement
The statistics follow the filter, values and measure selected at the top of the page.
Stock market cycle statistics
Leads and lags: cross-correlations with output
Correlation between each variable \(k\) quarters ahead, \(x_{t+k}\), and output today, \(y_t\). A peak at negative \(k\) means the variable tends to move before output (it leads); at positive \(k\), after output (it lags). The peak is the largest correlation in absolute value, highlighted in each row.
Correlation matrix: stock market indicators
Contemporaneous correlations between the cyclical components of the stock-market series. Blue cells are positive, orange cells negative; darker cells are stronger correlations.
Correlation matrix: business cycles and the stock market
The variables of the Real Business Cycles page with stock prices and dividends (S&P 500). Select the variables to show below; the selection also applies to the leads-and-lags matrix.
Leads and lags: cross-correlation matrix
For each pair of variables, the correlation between the row variable \(k\) quarters ahead, \(x_{t+k}\), and the column variable today, \(z_t\), for \(k = -4, \dots, +4\). Each cell shows one of these nine correlations and, below it, the \(k\) at which it occurs: the strongest (largest in absolute value), the highest or the lowest, as chosen with the switch. Negative \(k\): the row variable tends to move before the column variable (it leads); positive \(k\): after it (it lags).
Definitions and methods
The series
- Stock prices, dividends and earnings (S&P 500): quarterly averages of Robert J. Shiller’s monthly data: the price of the S&P Composite index (the S&P 500 from 1957), and dividends and earnings over the past twelve months per share of the index. See Main Stock Market Indicators for their definitions.
- Corporate dividends (NIPA): net dividends paid by US corporations in the national income and product accounts (FRED: DIVIDEND), the aggregate counterpart of the dividends of a model economy; per capita, divided by the population (B230RC0Q173SBEA).
- Price–dividend ratio and CAPE: the S&P 500 price over twelve-month dividends, and the real price over the average of real earnings in the previous ten years (Campbell and Shiller, 1988).
- Real values: nominal values divided by the GDP price index (GDPDEF, 2017 = 100). The ratios are the same in real and nominal terms.
- Output and the macroeconomic variables: in real terms, the cycles published on the Real Business Cycles page, unchanged. In nominal terms, the current-dollar series (GDP, PCEC, GPDI, GCE, EXPGS, IMPGS; hourly compensation COMPNFB; nominal output per hour = OPHNFB × IPDNBS / 100, the nonfarm business price deflator), filtered from 1947 Q1 in the same way, total or per capita (BEA population).
Filters and statistics
Every series is filtered as \(100 \times \ln x_t\) on its quarterly values from 1947 Q1, the start of the series of the Real Business Cycles page, so that the stock cycles and the macroeconomic cycles are measured over the same history; a cycle value of 10 means the series is about 10 percent above its trend. The filters are those of Real Business Cycles: Hodrick–Prescott (λ = 1600; Hodrick and Prescott, 1997), Hamilton (2018; h = 8, p = 4) and Christiano–Fitzgerald (2003; 6–32 quarters).
The statistics use the quarters from 1950 Q1 that each pair of series covers: the standard deviation of the cycle, its ratio to that of output, the first-order autocorrelation and the correlation with output; the cross-correlations follow Kydland and Prescott (1990).
References
- Campbell, J. Y. and R. J. Shiller (1988). “Stock Prices, Earnings, and Expected Dividends.” Journal of Finance 43(3): 661–676.
- Christiano, L. J. and T. J. Fitzgerald (2003). “The Band Pass Filter.” International Economic Review 44(2): 435–465.
- Hamilton, J. D. (2018). “Why You Should Never Use the Hodrick-Prescott Filter.” Review of Economics and Statistics 100(5): 831–843.
- Hodrick, R. J. and E. C. Prescott (1997). “Postwar U.S. Business Cycles: An Empirical Investigation.” Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 29(1): 1–16.
- Kydland, F. E. and E. C. Prescott (1990). “Business Cycles: Real Facts and a Monetary Myth.” Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Quarterly Review 14(2): 3–18.
- Shiller, R. J. (1981). “Do Stock Prices Move Too Much to Be Justified by Subsequent Changes in Dividends?” American Economic Review 71(3): 421–436.
- Shiller, R. J. (2015). Irrational Exuberance, 3rd edition. Princeton University Press. Data: shillerdata.com
Page created on 20/11/2026.
© Arthur Galichère.
- Errors: Every effort has been made to ensure the data and calculations are accurate; any remaining errors are mine. If you believe you have found a mistake, or have a comment or suggestion, please let me know.
- Reuse and citation: Stock-market data are Robert J. Shiller’s (shillerdata.com); corporate dividends, the GDP price index, population and the macroeconomic series are from the agencies named under each chart, via FRED (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis), and from John Fernald at the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. The cycles, statistics, charts and text are the author’s. When reusing these figures, please cite the original data providers and this website: Arthur Galichère, Stock Market Cycles.